Restraint of Trade Clause Checklist for Buying a Business in Australia
A restraint of trade clause in an Australian business sale stops the seller from competing with you after settlement. It sounds simple. In practice, it's one of the most negotiated — and most poorly drafted — clauses in a business sale agreement, and the cost of getting it wrong is paid after the seller has walked out with your money.
A restraint of trade clause is enforceable in Australia when it protects a legitimate business interest, is reasonable in scope, and doesn't go further than necessary to protect the buyer. That last condition is the one that trips up most deals. Courts won't automatically enforce a restraint just because both parties signed it — if the scope is excessive, a court can void it entirely or blue-pencil it down to something narrower than you intended. Understanding the restraint of trade clause when buying a business before you're sitting at a settlement table is the whole game.
Why Most Restraint Clauses Aren't Worth the Paper
I reviewed a business sale agreement last year where the restraint clause had a five-year, Australia-wide restriction on a sole-operator pest control business in Ballarat. The seller signed it without blinking. The buyer thought they were protected.
They weren't. A restraint of that breadth — covering an entire continent for five years for a local service business — would almost certainly fail if challenged. Courts in Australia assess reasonableness against the actual geographic reach of the business, the nature of its customer relationships, and the time needed for goodwill to transfer to the new owner. Ballarat pest control doesn't need a national restraint.
The problem is that overly broad clauses feel protective. They feel comprehensive. They feel like you've covered every angle. What they actually do is increase the risk that a court collapses the whole thing when the seller walks back into the market two months after settlement.
The Three Variables That Define a Restraint
Every restraint of trade clause in Australian business acquisitions has three dimensions. All three need to be right:
Geographic scope. This should match the actual trading area of the business. A plumbing business operating in the Inner West of Sydney doesn't need a NSW-wide restraint. A landscaping business with clients across metropolitan Melbourne needs broader geographic protection than one covering two suburbs.
Duration. Courts have generally accepted two to three years as reasonable for small service businesses. Five years is sometimes upheld for larger businesses or those with significant goodwill components. Anything beyond five years attracts scrutiny. Industry matters too — a business with long-term contracts may justify a longer period than one with episodic transactional revenue.
Activities restrained. The clause should specifically name the activities the seller is prohibited from doing, not use vague catch-all language. "Engaging in a business that competes" is weaker than "providing carpet cleaning services to residential and commercial customers within [defined area]."
This is covered in depth in Module 7 of the Playbook, which walks through the full negotiation and closing process from offer to settlement.
What to Do Before You Sign
Before signing any sale and purchase agreement with a restraint clause, three things are non-negotiable:
First, have a solicitor who understands business acquisitions — not just conveyancing — review the clause against the specific circumstances of the business. The sale and purchase agreement as a whole needs commercial review, but the restraint is the clause most likely to be challenged.
Second, check whether the restraint applies to all sellers. If there are multiple shareholders or directors, the restraint should bind each of them individually, not just the corporate entity. A business where the key person is the seller's adult child — who never signed anything — is not protected.
Third, understand the remedies. What happens if the seller breaches the restraint? Does the agreement specify liquidated damages? Does it entitle you to an injunction without proving actual loss? Remedies are as important as the restraint itself — a clause with no practical enforcement mechanism is mostly decorative.
Get the full checklist below — it covers the clause review, negotiation flags, and post-settlement monitoring in one place. The Business Acquisition Negotiation Checklist and SPA Key Terms Checklist are also worth having for the broader negotiation.
Get the free Restraint of Trade Checklist
Enter your email to unlock the full resource. You'll also get weekly insights on buying businesses in Australia.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.