The Owner Dependency Scorecard
Instructions: Score each dimension 1–5 based on the criteria below. Be honest — score what you observe, not what the seller tells you. Total the seven scores. Interpretation guide is at the bottom.
Dimension 1: Revenue Generation
Who generates new revenue for the business?
| Score | Description |
|---|
| 1 | All new revenue comes from the owner — personal relationships, direct referrals, on-site selling |
| 2 | Most revenue is owner-generated; some comes from repeat work with existing accounts |
| 3 | Revenue is split — owner generates roughly half; the rest comes from inbound leads or repeat business |
| 4 | Most revenue is inbound, repeat, or generated by the team; owner handles exceptions |
| 5 | Revenue generation is fully systematised — CRM, marketing systems, or long-term contracts; owner not required |
Your score: ___/5
Notes/Evidence: _______________________________________________
Dimension 2: Customer Relationships
Who holds the relationships with key customers?
| Score | Description |
|---|
| 1 | All significant customer relationships are personal to the owner; customers call the owner's mobile |
| 2 | Most key relationships are owner-held; a few accounts accept contact from other staff |
| 3 | Relationships are mixed — some are personal to the owner, others are account-managed by staff |
| 4 | Most customer relationships are held at the business level; the owner is available but not required |
| 5 | All key customer relationships are documented, account-managed, and contractually held by the business entity |
Your score: ___/5
Notes/Evidence: _______________________________________________
Red flag trigger: if the top three customers all have the owner's personal mobile saved as "Dave" or "Mick", score this a 1 regardless of what else you observe.
Dimension 3: Technical Skills and Licences
Can the business operate without the owner's technical input?
| Score | Description |
|---|
| 1 | Owner holds the only qualified licence or technical certification required to operate; no succession plan |
| 2 | Owner is the primary technical lead; one other staff member has partial qualifications but is not licensed |
| 3 | At least one other qualified person exists but is not in a senior role; owner handles complex work |
| 4 | Multiple qualified staff; owner's technical role could be replaced with reasonable effort |
| 5 | Business does not depend on owner's personal qualifications; all required licences are held at business or employee level |
Your score: ___/5
Notes/Evidence: _______________________________________________
Australian trades note: check whether the business holds a contractor's licence under state legislation (e.g. Queensland Building and Construction Commission, NSW Fair Trading, Victorian Building Authority) or whether the licence is personal to the owner. These are different things.
Dimension 4: Staff Management and Culture
Can staff operate independently without the owner directing them?
| Score | Description |
|---|
| 1 | Owner makes all decisions; staff wait for direction before acting; no one has management authority |
| 2 | Senior staff can handle routine tasks unsupervised; escalate anything non-standard to owner |
| 3 | One capable senior employee or supervisor can manage day-to-day operations; owner handles strategy and exceptions |
| 4 | Functional management team exists; owner is consulted but not required for most decisions |
| 5 | Business has a general manager or operations manager who runs the business; owner is effectively a non-executive shareholder |
Your score: ___/5
Notes/Evidence: _______________________________________________
Question to ask in due diligence: "If you took a month off tomorrow with no notice, what would happen?" The answer — and the expression when they hear the question — tells you more than the financials.
Dimension 5: Processes and Documentation
Are the business's systems documented and transferable?
| Score | Description |
|---|
| 1 | No documented processes; all knowledge is in the owner's head; no SOPs, no documented pricing, no written procedures |
| 2 | Minimal documentation — maybe a price list and some ad hoc notes; most operational knowledge is undocumented |
| 3 | Core processes are partially documented; some SOPs exist for common tasks; staff can follow basic procedures |
| 4 | Most processes are documented and accessible; a new manager could learn the business from the existing materials |
| 5 | Fully documented operations manual; SOPs for all key tasks; documented pricing, quoting, supplier terms, and customer management processes |
Your score: ___/5
Notes/Evidence: _______________________________________________
Dimension 6: Supplier and Subcontractor Relationships
Are key supplier and subcontractor relationships personal to the owner?
| Score | Description |
|---|
| 1 | All key supplier terms, credit accounts, and subcontractor relationships are personal to the owner; likely to change on sale |
| 2 | Most supplier relationships are owner-dependent; some accounts are in the business name but maintained by the owner |
| 3 | Supplier accounts are mostly in the business name; some credit terms may need renegotiation post-sale |
| 4 | All supplier accounts are in the business name; existing terms are not personal to the owner |
| 5 | Supplier relationships are systematised with documented account managers, negotiated terms, and no personal dependency |
Your score: ___/5
Notes/Evidence: _______________________________________________
Worth checking: whether trade credit accounts (with suppliers like Reece, Tradelink, Middy's, or Blackwoods) are in the business name or the owner's personal name. This affects what credit terms transfer with the sale.
Dimension 7: Business Development and Strategy
Can the business identify and pursue growth opportunities without the owner?
| Score | Description |
|---|
| 1 | Owner is the sole driver of all growth; no staff member understands the business's market position or strategy |
| 2 | Owner directs strategy; one or two staff could execute on specific tasks if directed |
| 3 | Senior staff understand the business well enough to maintain current trajectory; growth still requires owner input |
| 4 | Business has a functional pipeline or business development process that doesn't require daily owner involvement |
| 5 | Business has a documented strategy, a pipeline process, and staff capable of executing growth without the owner |
Your score: ___/5
Notes/Evidence: _______________________________________________
Total Score Interpretation
Add your seven dimension scores and interpret below.
| Total Score | Dependency Level | What It Means for Buyers |
|---|
| 7–14 | Extreme | The business is the owner. Without them, revenue and relationships walk out the door. Either pass on the deal, or structure it as an earn-out where the owner stays for 2–3 years. Price should reflect the high probability of customer attrition. Discount multiple by 30–40%. |
| 15–21 | High | Significant dependency exists in multiple dimensions. Workable if: (a) the owner agrees to a 12–18 month handover, (b) you or a hired operator can absorb the dependency over time, or (c) you structure the deal with an earn-out tied to customer retention. Expect a multiple discount of 15–25%. |
| 22–28 | Moderate | Some dependency exists but the business has functional systems and staff who can handle day-to-day operations. Focus your negotiation on the specific dimensions with low scores. Handover period of 3–6 months is usually sufficient. Negotiate on price if specific risks are significant. |
| 29–35 | Low | The business can operate independently. Owner dependency is not a material risk. Standard due diligence applies. This is the profile you want — and in Australian small business, it's rarer than you'd think. |
Dimension-Specific Red Flags
Even if the total score is reasonable, watch for these individual patterns:
-
Dimension 3 score of 1 or 2 (licences): This is a deal-stopper unless you can arrange a replacement licence holder before settlement. In some trades, this takes months.
-
Dimension 2 score of 1 (customer relationships): Ask the seller to introduce you to the top five customers before you sign anything. Their reaction — and the customers' — tells you whether the relationships are transferable.
-
Dimension 5 score of 1 (documentation): Budget 60–90 days of the seller's time post-settlement to document what's in their head. Include this in the transition agreement. Without it, you'll spend six months reverse-engineering the business.
-
Dimension 4 score of 1 with Dimension 7 score of 1: The owner is both the manager and the strategist. You're not buying a business — you're buying a job. Price accordingly, or pass.
Using This Scorecard in Negotiations
A low total score is not a reason to walk away. It's a negotiating instrument.
If the business scores 15–21 (high dependency), you have legitimate grounds to:
- Request an extended transition period (12–18 months) as part of the sale terms
- Propose an earn-out structure where a portion of the purchase price is contingent on customer retention in year one
- Negotiate a lower headline multiple (e.g. 2x instead of 3x EBITDA) to reflect the risk you're absorbing
- Require specific seller warranties about named customer intentions and contract status
Document your scorecard findings and use them to build your position in writing before any negotiation meeting. A number is harder to argue with than an impression.
This scorecard is part of Module 2 of the Playbook. For the full due diligence process that follows this assessment, use the Due Diligence Checklist for Buying a Business in Australia. To go deeper on finding and evaluating acquisition targets, read finding a profitable business to buy and explore the full framework at /playbook.