Earn-Out Agreement Negotiation Checklist for Australian Business Buyers

Nigel Gordon··Deal Structure & Financing

An earn-out agreement is a deal structure in which part of the business purchase price is paid after settlement, contingent on the business hitting agreed financial targets — typically EBITDA, gross profit, or revenue — over one to three years. In Australian small business acquisitions, earn-outs typically appear when the seller and buyer disagree on price, or when the business's performance is tied to the seller staying actively involved after the sale.

They're also one of the more reliable ways for an acquisition to turn into a drawn-out dispute.

The earn-out checklist below gives you a structured process for evaluating whether to accept an earn-out, negotiating the terms, protecting yourself in the sale and purchase agreement, and managing the earn-out period through to final payment. It maps to Module 6 of the Playbook on deal structure and financing.


When earn-outs come up — and when to be suspicious

Sellers propose earn-outs for a few different reasons, and it's worth understanding which one you're dealing with before you agree to anything.

The legitimate reason: the seller believes the business will grow significantly after the sale and wants to share in that upside. The less comfortable reason: the seller knows there are risks in the business that make the current asking price hard to justify on current financials alone (which is a way of saying the seller's confidence in the business is somewhat lower than their asking price suggests).

I've seen a deal where a buyer accepted an earn-out tied to revenue, only to discover post-settlement that the seller had forward-sold some long-term contracts to accelerate revenue in the earn-out year. The contracts were legitimate. The timing was not an accident. A well-drafted earn-out agreement would have caught it — that's what this checklist is designed to help you build.

Before reaching for the full checklist below, read our guide to earn-out agreements for the strategic context on when earn-outs work and when they backfire.


Three things to lock in before the detailed negotiation

If you're going to accept an earn-out, these three items need to be agreed in principle before the lawyers start drafting — because they shape everything else:

1. The metric. Revenue, gross profit, EBITDA, or EBIT each produce very different outcomes for the buyer. Revenue is the easiest to hit but the hardest to manipulate downward; EBITDA gives the seller the most opportunity to inflate expenses in the earn-out period. Agree on the metric before you discuss the number.

2. The calculation methodology. Two reasonable accountants can calculate EBITDA for the same business and reach different numbers (this should not be a surprise to anyone who has ever been in a due diligence). The methodology — which costs are included, how depreciation is treated, how owner costs are normalised — needs to be agreed and locked in writing. Not summarised in an email. Agreed in the SPA.

3. The base-case scenario. If the earn-out produces zero, does the deal still make sense? Model this before you sign. If the answer is no, you either need a higher base price or you need to walk.

For a full comparison of earn-outs against other deal structures — vendor finance, staged payments, equity rollovers — see the Deal Structure Comparison Framework.


What's in the full checklist

The gated resource below covers 35 specific items across five phases:

  • Phase 1 — Should you accept an earn-out at all? (7 items)
  • Phase 2 — Negotiating the earn-out terms (14 items)
  • Phase 3 — Protecting yourself in the SPA (8 items)
  • Phase 4 — Managing the earn-out period (7 items)
  • Phase 5 — Completing and closing out the earn-out (5 items including dispute triggers)

Each item includes a brief explanation of why it matters and what to watch for — not just a checkbox.

If you're negotiating vendor finance as part of the same deal, the Vendor Finance Negotiation Checklist covers the debt side; this checklist covers the performance-linked component.

Get the free earn-out checklist

Enter your email to unlock the full resource. You'll also get weekly insights on buying businesses in Australia.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.