Is This Business Asking Price Fair? The Buyer's Verification Checklist

Nigel Gordon··Valuation & Pricing

Checking whether a business asking price is fair in Australia comes down to one question: does the normalised EBITDA — after removing non-recurring and owner-specific expenses — justify the multiple being asked, relative to comparable transactions in that industry? If the answer is yes and there are no material hidden liabilities, the price is defensible. If the answer is no, you either renegotiate or walk away.

That sounds simple. The complication is that sellers (and some brokers) put a lot of effort into making the EBITDA look larger and the risk look smaller than it actually is.

This checklist helps you cut through that in a structured way. It's the same process I work through on any deal I'm evaluating — not a theoretical framework but a practical sequence of checks that takes the headline price and tests it against reality.

Why Buyers Overpay (and Why This Checklist Exists)

Most overpayments I've seen don't happen because the buyer was naive. They happen because the buyer accepted the seller's version of the numbers without independently testing them. The seller's accountant produces an add-backs schedule. It looks professional. The buyer assumes someone else has already checked it.

Nobody has.

A broker told me about a deal last year in which the buyer paid 4.2x what they thought was normalised EBITDA. After settlement, they discovered that two of the largest add-backs — "one-off equipment hire" and "COVID relief grant repayment" — had quietly appeared in three consecutive years of financials. The normalised EBITDA was about 30% smaller than advertised. The price was fine at 3x; at 4.2x it was going to be a hard few years.

This checklist exists so you don't have that conversation with yourself post-settlement.

What's in the Full Checklist

The complete checklist walks you through six phases:

  • Phase 1: EBITDA Reality Check — verifying the headline earnings figure is actually supported by the books
  • Phase 2: Industry Multiple Benchmark — comparing the asking price to what similar businesses actually sell for in Australia
  • Phase 3: Add-Backs Deep Dive — testing each owner add-back against documentation and recurrence
  • Phase 4: Working Capital Assessment — making sure you're not inheriting a cash shortfall at settlement
  • Phase 5: Hidden Liability Scan — the costs and risks that don't show up in the profit and loss
  • Phase 6: Independent Verification — when and how to get a second opinion before you commit

Use it alongside the EBITDA add-backs verification checklist and the industry multiples cheat sheet for a complete picture.

For the full article on the methodology behind each check, see how to avoid overpaying for a business in Australia. The valuation section of Module 4 of the Playbook covers the underlying framework in depth.

Three Things to Do Before You Start

Before working through the checklist, make sure you have:

  1. Three years of financials — not just the information memorandum summary. Ask for the actual tax returns and management accounts. If the seller won't provide three years, ask why.
  2. A month-by-month revenue breakdown — to check for seasonality, one-off spikes, and whether revenue is trending up or down.
  3. The add-backs schedule — the document where the seller or their accountant lists every adjustment they've made to arrive at the "normalised" EBITDA figure.

If any of these three items are unavailable before you sign a heads of agreement (and especially before you pay for due diligence), that's a red flag worth addressing before you spend money.

Get the free price verification checklist

Enter your email to unlock the full resource. You'll also get weekly insights on buying businesses in Australia.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.