Deferred Payment Structure When Buying a Business in Australia
Deferred consideration is one of those terms that gets used loosely in business sale negotiations — sometimes to mean vendor finance, sometimes earn-outs, sometimes something else entirely. They're not the same thing. Understanding the difference matters, because each structure carries different risks, different tax treatment, and different leverage for both sides.
Here's what deferred consideration actually is, when it makes sense to use it, and what you need to do to make sure you don't end up paying for a business that's already gone south by the time you settle the second tranche.
What Is Deferred Consideration?
Deferred consideration is a fixed amount of the purchase price that is not paid at settlement — it's paid at a specified future date or in instalments. The total price is agreed upfront. The timing of payment is split.
Say you agree to buy a landscaping business for $600,000. You pay $450,000 at settlement and the remaining $150,000 twelve months later. That $150,000 is deferred consideration. The seller knows they'll get it. You know you owe it. Neither amount varies based on future performance.
That last point is what distinguishes it from an earn-out.
How Deferred Consideration Differs from an Earn-Out
An earn-out ties part of the purchase price to future business performance. If the business hits agreed milestones in the year after settlement, the seller gets the earn-out payment. If it doesn't, they get less (or nothing).
Deferred consideration has no performance condition. The seller will receive that payment regardless of what happens to the business under your ownership. You owe it even if revenue drops, a key customer walks, or the previous owner's golden touch turns out to have been entirely dependent on their relationships (more common than sellers like to admit).
This is why buyers should think hard before agreeing to large deferred consideration without adequate protections. You're on the hook for a fixed amount based on a valuation that was set before you took the keys.
How It Differs from Vendor Finance
Vendor finance is effectively a loan from the seller. They fund part of the purchase price, you repay it over time with interest. The seller becomes a creditor.
Deferred consideration is not a loan structure — it's a staged payment of the agreed purchase price. There's typically no interest component (though this is negotiable, and the ATO may impute interest if none is specified). The seller isn't acting as a financier; they're simply waiting for a portion of their money.
The practical difference: vendor finance often comes with a formal security arrangement (a charge over the business assets) and an ongoing repayment schedule. Deferred consideration tends to be treated as a simple contractual obligation — which means if you're the seller, you need to think carefully about what happens if the buyer doesn't pay.
If you want to understand the full range of structures, the Deal Structure Comparison Framework lays out vendor finance, earn-outs, deferred consideration, and equity rollover side by side.
Why Would a Seller Agree to This?
Sellers accept deferred consideration for a few reasons — and understanding their motivations gives you leverage in negotiations.
Valuation disagreement. The most common reason. You think the business is worth $500,000; the seller thinks it's worth $650,000. Deferred consideration can bridge that gap without either party fully conceding. You pay $500,000 at settlement and an additional $100,000 twelve months later. The seller gets closer to their number; you get time to verify the business performs as represented before the final payment falls due.
Tax timing. Some sellers prefer not to receive the full proceeds in a single financial year. Spreading the payment across two financial years can reduce the effective capital gains tax burden. Sellers should get specific advice from their accountant on this — the ATO has rules about how deferred consideration is taxed, and they're not simple.
Confidence in the transition. A seller who's genuinely confident the business will perform well under new ownership might be willing to wait for part of their money. It's not charity; they know they'll get paid.
What Should Be in the SPA
The sale and purchase agreement needs to deal with deferred consideration carefully. I've seen deals where the deferred payment clause was three sentences long and the buyer ended up in a dispute with the seller eighteen months later over whether certain representations made at the time of sale entitled them to reduce the payment. It was messy (and expensive).
Your SPA should address:
Payment trigger and timing. The exact date the deferred consideration falls due. Or if it's instalment-based, the schedule. Avoid vague language like "within a reasonable time."
Interest. Whether interest accrues, at what rate, and from when. The ATO may impute interest on interest-free arrangements — currently at the benchmark interest rate — and treat it as income for the seller. Get your accountant to advise here.
Offset rights. This is the buyer's key protection. You should have the right to offset the deferred consideration against any warranty claims that have been validated. If the seller represented that the business had no outstanding employee entitlements and you discover $40,000 in unpaid super after settlement, you want to be able to deduct that from the deferred payment rather than paying in full and then chasing the seller separately.
Circumstances where payment is reduced or delayed. If a specific condition is relevant to the deferred payment — say, a material contract with a major customer — the SPA should specify what happens if that contract is lost before the payment date.
Security. What protection does the seller have if you don't pay? Options include a charge over business assets, a personal guarantee, or a capped bank guarantee. Sellers will push for security; buyers should negotiate the least burdensome form acceptable.
Security Arrangements — The Bit Most Buyers Ignore
Here's the thing most buyers focus too little on until it's too late: if the seller has taken a charge over the business assets as security for the deferred payment, they can effectively reclaim those assets if you default. This can be existential for a business that's been trading for twelve months and built new goodwill of its own.
Before agreeing to a charge, consider:
- Whether the charge ranks below or above your bank's security (your bank will have an opinion)
- Whether the charge covers just the original business assets or the entire business as it exists at the payment date
- What the enforcement process looks like and what notice you'd receive before enforcement
None of this is a reason to avoid deferred consideration. It's a reason to have your solicitor review the security arrangements before you sign anything.
Negotiating Deferred Consideration Effectively
A few things I've seen work well in negotiations:
Tie the deferred payment to a specific verifiable condition, not just time. Rather than "pay in twelve months," consider "pay in twelve months unless warranty claims exceed $X, in which case the payment is reduced by the value of validated claims." This converts some of the risk back to the seller.
Reduce the deferred amount to something you'd be comfortable losing. If the business deteriorates significantly after settlement and a warranty dispute drags on, you may end up paying legal fees that exceed the amount in dispute. Deferred consideration works best as a relatively modest proportion of the purchase price — under 20% is common — not as a mechanism for funding a large chunk of the deal.
Check how vendor finance compares for your situation. Vendor finance gives you better ongoing flexibility and clear repayment terms. Deferred consideration is simpler but less flexible. For deals where cashflow in the first twelve months is tight, vendor finance stretched over three to five years often makes more sense.
Tax Treatment — Get Advice Before You Agree to Structure
Both buyer and seller should get specific tax advice before agreeing to a deferred consideration structure. The main issues:
For sellers: the full capital gain typically arises at the date of sale, even if the proceeds are received over time. This catches some sellers off guard — they expected the tax to be spread across the payment years, but the ATO's default position is that the CGT event happens at contract date. There are some exceptions and elections available, but they're not automatic.
For buyers: deferred consideration forms part of the cost base of the business assets. How it's allocated across individual assets in the purchase price allocation affects future depreciation claims. Worth getting right at the time of the deal rather than trying to fix it later.
A broker I know described a deal where the buyer had agreed to a large deferred consideration amount, the accountant had been brought in after the SPA was signed, and the entire structure had to be renegotiated because the tax outcomes for both parties were worse than expected. Getting the accountant in earlier would have been cheaper than the renegotiation (and would have kept the deal alive — it nearly fell over).
When Not to Use Deferred Consideration
Deferred consideration is a tool, not a default mechanism. Avoid it when:
- The business is heavily dependent on the outgoing owner and you're uncertain the revenue will hold (an earn-out is more appropriate here — it aligns the seller's payout with actual performance)
- You're already carrying significant bank debt and the offset risk isn't something your accountant has modelled
- The seller has shown any signs of becoming difficult post-settlement — deferred consideration keeps them financially engaged with your business in a way that can create leverage you don't want them to have
This Is Module 6 of the Playbook
Deal structure is one of the more nuanced parts of buying a business. Deferred consideration, vendor finance, earn-outs, equity rollover — each has a place, and the right choice depends on your financial position, the nature of the business, and the seller's circumstances. This is covered in depth in Module 6 of the Playbook.
For more on structuring deals, read how earn-outs work, vendor finance basics, and the sale and purchase agreement.
If you found this useful, The Leveraged Worker newsletter covers this kind of practical acquisition detail every week — deals I'm looking at, structures I've seen, mistakes worth avoiding.
FAQ
Is deferred consideration the same as vendor finance?
No. Deferred consideration is a staged payment of an agreed fixed price with no interest (unless specified). Vendor finance is a loan from the seller with an interest component and a formal repayment schedule. Both involve the seller waiting for some of their money, but the structure and documentation differ.
When does the capital gain arise for a seller accepting deferred consideration?
Under the standard ATO position, the capital gains tax event arises at the contract date — not when each payment is received. This means the full gain may be assessable in the year of sale even if proceeds are received over multiple years. Sellers should seek specific tax advice before agreeing to this structure.
Can I offset warranty claims against deferred consideration?
Yes, if the SPA includes an offset right. This is a standard buyer protection and worth negotiating firmly. Without it, you'd need to pursue warranty claims separately while still paying the full deferred amount.
How much of the purchase price is typically deferred?
There's no fixed rule, but deferred consideration above 20-25% of the total price starts to introduce meaningful risk for buyers. Smaller amounts are easier to manage and dispute if warranty claims arise.
Does the seller need security over the deferred payment?
Sellers will often request a charge over business assets or a personal guarantee. Buyers should negotiate the least restrictive security arrangement acceptable, and ensure any charge ranks appropriately relative to bank lending.